Gender identity disorder from a social constructionist perspective
Uncovering the social nature of gender categories is important not only for general metaphysical purposes but also, and primarily, for political reasons. This paper reviews selected literature on a the epidemiology of BPD, b gender bias in the diagnosis of BPD, and c the social construction of diagnosis, particularly the diagnostic entity labeled "Borderline Personality Disorder.
Social construction of masculinity and femininity pdf
And if it has an impact on the development of dissociative disorders, including behavioral patterns, experiences, and symptoms, then in this case, cultural background shapes the disorder. The former partly grounds the latter, or, put differently, the latter can be metaphysically explained in terms of the former. Kathoey Thailand Kathoey. What Eckert is instead stating is that this is a common misconception that a majority of the population unknowingly reinforces, which sees its emergence during infancy. Stereotype ideas and beliefs regarding women, although they have been changed and improved, are still evident in our country and in other modern cultures. An alcoholic exemplifies a specific psychological property, which, in turn, is supposed to exemplify the property of being a mental disorder. Some consequences for psychiatric explanation and, thus, for psychiatry as a science are highlighted in the conclusion. The criteria for classification can be genitalia at birth or chromosomal typing before birth, and they do not necessarily agree with one another". Any at least partly successful attempt to deliver a general answer to the question of what social constructivism is would transcend the boundaries of the present paper; but a general answer is not required — the theses we will be concerned with here are committed to the social dimension of their targets such as particular mental disorders in a straightforward sense; and we will be able to relate, in passing, these cases to intuitive formulations of social constructivism.
Little reflection will reveal that cultural influence on patient—clinician interaction is irrelevant in the context of social constructivism about psychiatry, properly construed. Gender identity seems to refer to some quasi-metaphysical property or essence that is fixed, unchanging, and may not be challenged.
This means that some of these theories assume a clear biological division between women and men when considering the social creation of masculinity and femininity, while other contest the assumption of the biological division between the sexes as independent of social construction.
Ultimately, language has a huge influence on how humans perceive reality and, as a result, is the creator of this reality. Facts about social norms are clearly social facts.
Social construction of gender ppt
However, the way a condition is presented to a subject from the first person perspective may involve a social dimension. According to social constructionism, individuals can create meaning only in relation to what they are exposed to in their environment. The fact that the disorder has a cause of a particular type grounds the fact that it is a disorder of the corresponding subtype for instance, disorder caused by an interpersonal and intentional stressor, or PTSD due to torture. Still, it is not entirely clear how to cash out, and account for, the relevance of perceived social causes within the radical objectivist framework. It appears that there are causal versions of social constructivism in psychiatry. I recently attended a baby shower party and I was shocked first by the amount of items a baby needs and even more about the color choice of each item. Does the claim that clinicians should be sensitive the culture-specific articulations of the underlying disorder constitute a version of social constructivism, in any interesting sense? Butler is, however, not stating that gender is a sort of performance in which an individual can terminate the act; instead, what Butler is stating is that this performance is ongoing and out of an individual's control. A large part of the evaporation of water is currently caused by global warming or so let us assume for the sake of the example. Particularly in television, men are usually shown as being nonemotional and detached. Speech[ edit ] Anatomical studies have shown that the larynx of a child, and by extension the fundamental frequency, is likely to vary directly as a result of size and height, rather than sex. The targets are disorders, and the grounds are experiences, phenomenology, or symptoms that are individuated only with respect to a social context. But signs of a disorder need not play an essential role in scientific classification.
Littman surveyed parents about their teen and young adult children who became gender dysphoric and transgender-identified in the context of belonging to a peer group where one, multiple, or even all the friends in a pre-existing peer group became transgender-identified in a similar time frame, an increase in social media use, or both.
For instance children are constantly bombarded with shows depicting gender stereotype models from toys marketed as for boys or girls, to children's TV programs and shows.
Is that right? The authors suggest that whether or not a problematic experience is pathological depends in part on the social or cultural context. I have never thought about these things before.
The individual and society are indissoluble.
based on 91 review